NFL Teams Reassess Backup Quarterback Capabilities Ahead of 2025 Season
In the fast-paced arena of the NFL, the stability of a team’s quarterback position can make or break its season. As teams gear up for the 2025 season, the injury woes of the previous year serve as a stark reminder of the fragility of this pivotal role. Prominent players like Dak Prescott, Jordan Love, and Trevor Lawrence struggled with injuries, leaving their teams grappling for playoff contention. With this context, an analysis of each team’s backup quarterback situation reveals which franchises are best equipped to handle the adversity of an injury to their starter.
The Fragility of the Position
The past few NFL seasons have underscored the physical demands placed on quarterbacks. In 2022, a staggering 66 different quarterbacks started at least one game, highlighting the unpredictability and vulnerability of the position. The loss of a starting quarterback not only affects immediate playoff ambitions but can also derail long-term franchise plans. This reality prompts teams to reassess their backup options, determining which players could step up in case of an emergency.
Top 10 Backup Situations for 2025
Following thorough evaluations across the league, here are ten teams identified as having solid backup quarterback contingents for the upcoming season.
1. Minnesota Vikings
With a combination of youth and experience, the Vikings’ backup situation is anchored by a quarterback who is both a capable backup and a potential future starter. Howell, after gaining valuable experience with the Washington Commanders, brings a strong arm and dual-threat capabilities to support starter J.J. McCarthy.
2. San Francisco 49ers
Taking into account the unique offensive scheme employed by coach Kyle Shanahan, the 49ers possess the ideal fit in their backup. Notably, while he has yet to recapture past glory, the current backups have skills that can be harnessed effectively in their system, benefiting from a strong supporting cast.
3. New Orleans Saints
The Saints feature a backup known for his mobility and experience, key traits that are likely to be pivotal in a Kliff Kingsbury-style offensive setup. While he has had inconsistent performances, his dual-threat abilities could provide a much-needed spark should he be called into action.
4. Green Bay Packers
Willis, who stepped in for an injured Jordan Love, showcased efficiency and versatility during his limited gameplay. His ability to adapt quickly makes Green Bay confident in their backup situation moving into 2025.
5. Cleveland Browns
The Browns possess a unique dilemma with multiple mediocre options in their quarterback room. While not necessarily boasting standout talent, their backups have shown they can step in adequately if called upon.
6. Philadelphia Eagles
Despite having only one career start, backup McKee has demonstrated promise during practice and preseason games, making him an intriguing option behind Jalen Hurts. The Eagles have a history of elevating second-string quarterbacks to successful roles, adding to McKee’s potential.
7. Kansas City Chiefs
Minshew’s experience with the Las Vegas Raiders may not have panned out, but he remains a capable backup behind Patrick Mahomes. His unconventional playing style could give the Chiefs an advantage during a crucial game.
8. Indianapolis Colts
With Anthony Richardson as their likely starter, the Colts feature a backup whose skill set could translate well in their system. Jones has demonstrated toughness and mobility, providing safety in the event of an injury to Richardson.
9. Atlanta Falcons
Cousins remains a reliable option when healthy, and his experience in the league makes him a valuable asset. Described as a "borderline starter," he has the capability to step in and manage games effectively.
10. Los Angeles Rams
Finally, the Rams have acquired Garoppolo as insurance for Matthew Stafford’s health concerns. Despite Garoppolo’s injury past, he has led teams into meaningful playoff games, reinforcing Los Angeles’s strategic depth as they pursue another Lombardi Trophy.
Conclusion: The Importance of Backup Plans
As the NFL continues to evolve, the importance of having a competent backup quarterback cannot be overstated. The 2024 season’s injuries served as a crucial lesson for teams and fans alike, emphasizing the need for depth at the most important position in football. The teams listed here appear well-positioned to mitigate potential crises within their quarterback ranks, providing both resilience and stability as they strive for success in the 2025 season and beyond. In a league characterized by unpredictability, a solid backup plan could make all the difference.
